Advanced 20-Mark Series – Answer 6
Ethics vs Efficiency in Public Administration
Question
Advanced 20-Mark Model Answer
Efficiency has long been considered the central value of classical public administration. Thinkers such as Woodrow Wilson and Frederick Taylor emphasized economy, speed, and productivity as administrative goals. However, democratic governance also rests on ethical principles such as fairness, accountability, transparency, and justice.
The tension between ethics and efficiency emerges when administrative decisions prioritize output over values. For instance, rapid implementation of policies without adequate consultation may increase efficiency but weaken participatory legitimacy.
Dwight Waldo argued that public administration cannot be value-neutral; it inherently involves normative choices. Similarly, the New Public Administration movement emphasized social equity over mere efficiency.
In the Indian context, digital service delivery and Direct Benefit Transfer enhance efficiency, yet concerns regarding data privacy and exclusion highlight ethical dilemmas. Fast-track decision-making may conflict with due process and procedural fairness.
Effective governance requires integration rather than opposition of these values. Ethical frameworks, transparency mechanisms, and citizen participation can ensure that efficiency operates within democratic boundaries.
Thus, efficiency is necessary for administrative performance, but without ethical grounding, it risks eroding legitimacy and public trust. Sustainable governance depends on balancing performance with moral responsibility.
Prepared by Shaktimatha Learning
Waldo + NPA + Indian Context = 18+/20 Analytical Edge
No comments:
Post a Comment