PSIR – 20 Advanced 20-Mark Model Answer Series
Model Answer 19
“Deliberative democracy offers a corrective to the limitations of liberal representative democracy.” Critically examine. (20 Marks)
🔹 Introduction
Liberal representative democracy emphasizes elections, majority rule and constitutional rights. Deliberative democracy, influenced by thinkers like Habermas, stresses reasoned discussion and participatory dialogue as the basis of legitimate political decisions.
🔹 Features of Liberal Representative Democracy
- Periodic elections.
- Majority decision-making.
- Protection of individual rights.
- Representative institutions.
It ensures procedural legitimacy but may limit citizen engagement between elections.
🔹 Deliberative Democracy
- Public reasoning and dialogue.
- Consensus-building over mere voting.
- Participatory civic forums.
- Inclusion of marginalized voices.
Legitimacy flows from rational deliberation rather than numerical majority alone.
🔹 Limitations of Liberal Democracy
- Elite domination.
- Majoritarianism.
- Low civic participation.
- Polarization and populism.
🔹 Deliberative Correctives
- Strengthens democratic legitimacy.
- Encourages informed citizen participation.
- Reduces impulsive majoritarian decisions.
🔹 Criticisms of Deliberative Democracy
- Idealistic assumption of rational discourse.
- Power inequalities affect deliberation.
- Practical scalability issues.
🔹 Critical Evaluation
Deliberative democracy deepens democratic engagement and improves legitimacy. However, it cannot fully replace representative institutions. A hybrid model combining representation with deliberative mechanisms appears most viable.
🔹 Conclusion
Deliberative democracy provides a valuable corrective to the procedural limitations of liberal democracy by emphasizing participation and reasoned debate. The future of democracy lies in integrating both models.
Shaktimatha Learning – Advanced 20-Mark Model Answer Series
No comments:
Post a Comment