📘 PSIR – Political Theory | Page 7 Concept of Equality (From Formal Equality to Substantive Justice)
UPSC CSE Political Science & IR – Paper I Conceptual + Ideological + Mains-Oriented Notes | Shaktimatha Learning
1️⃣ What is Equality?
Equality does NOT mean sameness.
It means equal moral worth and equal consideration.
Aristotle defined equality as:
“Equals should be treated equally, unequals unequally.”
2️⃣ Formal Equality
Formal equality means equality before law.
- Equal legal rights
- No discrimination
- Rule of law
Example: Article 14 of Indian Constitution.
Limitation:
- Ignores social and economic inequalities
- Does not remove structural disadvantage
3️⃣ Substantive Equality
Substantive equality aims to reduce actual inequalities.
- Reservation policies
- Welfare programs
- Affirmative action
Recognizes that unequal people cannot be treated identically.
Linked with social justice.
4️⃣ Liberal View of Equality
Classical liberals:
- Equality before law
- Equality of opportunity
- Protection of individual liberty
Outcome inequality is acceptable.
Modern Liberalism (Rawls):
- Difference Principle
- Inequality allowed only if benefits least advantaged
5️⃣ Socialist / Marxist View
Economic equality is central.
Capitalism produces exploitation.
- Private property causes inequality
- Class system destroys equality
Goal: Classless society.
6️⃣ Feminist Perspective
Formal equality insufficient for women.
Patriarchal structures create hidden inequality.
- Wage gap
- Unpaid domestic labor
- Political under-representation
Feminism demands substantive gender justice.
7️⃣ Equality vs Liberty Debate
Too much equality may reduce freedom.
Too much liberty may increase inequality.
Modern democracies attempt balance.
8️⃣ Types of Equality
- Legal Equality
- Political Equality
- Social Equality
- Economic Equality
- Equality of Opportunity
- Equality of Outcome
9️⃣ Comparative Framework
| Approach | Focus | Limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Liberal | Opportunity | Ignores class |
| Marxist | Economic structure | May suppress liberty |
| Feminist | Gender justice | Identity complexity |
| Rawlsian | Fair inequality | Theoretical idealism |
🔟 Indian Constitutional Perspective
- Article 14 – Equality before law
- Article 15 – Prohibition of discrimination
- Article 16 – Equality of opportunity
- Reservation system – Substantive equality
UPSC MAINS APPLICATION
Expected Questions:
- “Is equality compatible with liberty?”
- “Distinguish between formal and substantive equality.”
- “Critically examine Rawls’ theory of justice.”
- “Does reservation violate equality?”
Answer Writing Strategy:
- Define equality clearly
- Explain ideological perspectives
- Compare approaches
- Add Indian examples
- Conclude with balance
Equality without justice is empty. Justice without equality is incomplete.
No comments:
Post a Comment