📘 PSIR – Political Theory | Page 13 Concept of Equality (Classical to Contemporary Debates)
UPSC CSE Political Science & IR – Paper I Conceptual + Analytical + Mains-Oriented Notes | Shaktimatha Learning
1️⃣ What is Equality?
Equality means absence of unjustified discrimination and ensuring equal moral worth of all individuals.
Equality does not mean sameness. It means fairness in treatment and opportunities.
2️⃣ Formal Equality (Equality Before Law)
- Equal legal status for all
- No special privileges
- Based on liberal tradition
Example: Article 14 – Equality before law.
Limitation: Ignores social and economic inequalities.
3️⃣ Substantive Equality
Recognizes that individuals are differently placed in society.
- Requires positive discrimination
- Affirmative action / Reservation
- Focus on real equality, not just formal equality
Indian Constitution supports substantive equality through reservations and welfare policies.
4️⃣ Marxist Perspective
Liberal equality is superficial.
- Political equality without economic equality is meaningless.
- Private property creates inequality.
- True equality requires abolition of class system.
Marx emphasizes material conditions over legal equality.
5️⃣ Rawls' Theory of Justice
John Rawls – A Theory of Justice
- Original Position
- Veil of Ignorance
- Two Principles of Justice
Difference Principle: Inequalities are justified only if they benefit the least advantaged.
Rawls combines liberty with distributive justice.
6️⃣ Feminist Perspective
Formal equality is insufficient.
- Patriarchy creates structural inequality
- Public/private divide hides oppression
- Need gender-sensitive equality
Introduces intersectional equality.
7️⃣ Types of Equality
- Legal Equality
- Political Equality
- Economic Equality
- Social Equality
- Equality of Opportunity
- Equality of Outcome
8️⃣ Equality in Indian Constitution
- Article 14 – Equality before Law
- Article 15 – Prohibition of Discrimination
- Article 16 – Equality of Opportunity in Public Employment
- Reservation Policies
Indian model combines liberal + social justice vision.
9️⃣ Comparative Understanding
| Perspective | Focus | Limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Liberal | Legal equality | Ignores economic gap |
| Marxist | Economic equality | May ignore liberty |
| Rawls | Fair distribution | Ideal theory critique |
| Feminist | Gender justice | Debate on universal application |
🔟 UPSC MAINS QUESTIONS
- Is equality compatible with liberty?
- Critically examine Rawls' theory of equality.
- Discuss difference between formal and substantive equality.
- Is reservation a tool of justice?
Answer Structure:
- Define equality
- Explain liberal perspective
- Introduce Marxist & Rawls critique
- Indian constitutional relevance
- Balanced conclusion
Equality without liberty is oppression. Liberty without equality is privilege.
No comments:
Post a Comment